The January 22 edition of the Arizona Star (Tucson) reprinted a piece from the Arizona Republic (Phoenix) titled “'I've never seen it this busy': Here's why Arizona emergency departments are jammed”. The article is paywalled, but you don’t really need to read it since that headline basically is the story: all over the state, including its two biggest cities, waits for non-emergencies (and sometimes emergencies) in ERs is many hours to, sometimes, days! The article discusses some reasons, including the increase this winter in respiratory diseases like flu, RSV, and, yes COVID (despite everyone pretending it has gone away; see NY Times “California and Oregon Ease Covid Isolation Rules, Breaking With C.D.C.”). In fact, there has been a lot of respiratory disease this winter, and as reported by “Your Local Epidemiologist”, Katelyn Jetelina, and while it seems to be declining, there could well be more peaks.
The colder weather makes the most vulnerable, those without
housing, even more vulnerable. Also contributing to the ER backup in Arizona is
the increase in the number of “winter visitors” (also known as “snowbirds”) who
are coming back “after” the pandemic, who are often older and do not have a
regular source of care here. And, yes, also that too many of us who live here
year round do not have a regular source of care because, as in most places,
there are not enough primary care clinicians (see “Primary
Care, Private Equity, and Profit: How to ensure poor quality care for the
American people”, Sept 28, 2023 and “We
need more primary care to serve our people: Why do the medical schools lie?”,
Dec 12, 2023). So people go to the emergency room, or to an urgent care center
where they are told to go to the emergency room “if it gets worse” or, when it
is serious enough, right away.
But there is something else going on here. That is the breakdown of the American health care system, particularly the insurance system and the ways people are covered (or not) for health care costs. It is breaking down at all levels: there are not enough doctors, especially in primary care (see the blog posts cited above), insurance companies and employers are covering less and less of the cost of health care and requiring those who have insurance to pay more and more, and private equity (see the referenced blog above) has taken over many practices and is squeezing them for maximum profit without regard to what it does to the quality of the “product”, which is our health care. Private equity in the healthcare sector follows the same playbook it follows everywhere: squeeze profit out, diminish services, and if it bankrupts the company too bad; they already have theirs. And when it is insurance companies that take over the practices (such as United Health Care owning Optum) the result is about the same. No one is minding the people-serving part of the store.
Yes, there are plenty of uninsured people, including the homeless, and those who are “too rich” (hah!) to get Medicaid, which in most states requires an income far below (often way less than half) the poverty level (which is about $31,000 for a family of 4), and anyway is also, in most states, pretty much limited to women with small children and virtually never covers single adults. But there are also the under-insured, those with terrible insurance coverage because it is all they can afford, as employers cut back on their contributions and insurance companies raise their rates and the financial burden on the insured including through copays, deductibles, and denied care (kind of like both raising the price and shrinking the size of a candy bar, except with much more serious outcomes). In addition, the expenditures by employers on health insurance (even when it is inadequate) is money that is not spent on wages, thereby increasing income inequality, as documented recently by Hager, Emanuel, and Mozaffarian in JAMA Open Network. And, since health insurance premiums are tax deductible for employers (although not for employees!) they prefer it to paying higher wages. What is the result of having insurance that doesn’t pay for what you hoped and expected it would when you or a family member is seriously ill? You go into debt. So the proportion of medical debt held by insured people as opposed to “self-pay” (uninsured, virtually all poor) people, has risen from 11.1% to 57.6% in 4 short years, from 2018 to 2022. Quintupled. The system, to the extent that it can be called a system at all, is broken.
But why? How? While there are still undoubtedly those, including politicians, pundits, and health administrators (all of them WELL-insured, you can be sure!) who blame it on some kind of “overuse” by patients (the medical word for “people”), there are actually 2 real causes:
- Abuse, corruption, and illegal behavior by insurance companies in pursuit of ever-more profit, and
- The failure of government entities to prevent them from doing so, or to prosecute them when they do.
Really? Really. Not only are insurance companies inadequately regulated, and able to effectively abstain from paying for care by repeatedly denying it and creating other obstacles, they frequently simply break the law, as documented in a study by ProPublica and reported by the Nonprofit Quarterly:
‘The findings point not just to bad behavior on the part of health insurance companies but also to a failure of the state regulatory apparatuses that oversee health insurance coverage to enforce laws already on the books: … If explicit laws on the books, spelling out mandatory coverage requirements, aren’t enough to prevent insurers from denying coverage, how are ordinary people to push back?
The answer, ProPublica’s Cheryl Clark found, is that those fighting for their own coverage are forced to navigate a “mind-boggling labyrinth” of bureaucracies set up by insurers and often barely regulated.”
It’s pretty bad, and it’s getting worse. Poor and uninsured people suffer the most, but employed and insured people are right behind them. Their medical debt increases in part because they think they have insurance and actually seek care, rather than avoiding it, as uninsured people often do. Which is, of course, terrible – how can there possibly be any justification at all for a “system” that encourages people to not seek care when they are sick, that provides too few primary care doctors or other clinicians to care for them, that makes them wait hours or days in ERs to be seen, and then saddles them with unpayable – but of course credit-destroying -- medical debt when they do get care?
Who are the worse criminals? The insurance companies and private equity firms who directly cause these problems by pursuing only maximum profit? Or the politicians who allow it to happen, who at best tinker around the edges, trying to limit (only occasionally with any success) the worst abuses? Should we run our fire departments like that? Police? The answer is in part tight regulation, prosecution of abuses and illegal activities including putting senior executives in prison, and really, finally, creating a universal coverage system in which each person has good coverage, can get good care, and be treated as a human being.
Like the executives, politicians and pundits expect for themselves.
