We don't need billionaires, we need a healthy population: It is time to move forward

I recently started reading Ricardo Nuila’s book “The People’s Hospital”, about Ben Taub, the largest public hospital in Houston. This will not be a book review (which can be found in many places, such as the NY Times, Washington Post, and elsewhere); I’ve just started it. What affected me was how, even in the first few pages, Nuila’s description of Ben Taub was so like that of Cook County Hospital (now John Stroger Hospital), the public hospital in Chicago where I did my family medicine residency and later practiced and taught for many years. That should not be surprising; the characteristics of large public hospitals in major cities, and especially the circumstances of the people who come to them for their health care (a major focus of the book, per the reviews) are going to be, sadly, very similar. What was most striking, and depressing, to me was the temporal aspect. Nuila is writing about recent years, including the impact of the COVID pandemic, while my years at Cook County were in the 1970s, 80s, and 90s. And yet so little has changed, especially not for the better.

Yes, medicine has changed. What we can (or, maybe more important, could) do for people is more. When I was a resident at County, CT scanners were uncommon, and didn’t exist at our hospital. If a patient needed a CT scan, it could usually be scheduled for after midnight at the private hospital across the street, if they were accompanied by the resident. Who had been up the entire previous night doing admissions. CT scans, and other imaging, are far easier to obtain now. We now have dozens, perhaps hundreds of more antibiotics, and are able to effectively treat many more infections, although bacterial resistance to them seems to grow faster than the antibiotics themselves, both because of overuse and the special breeding capacity of bacteria in hospitals where antibiotics are so pervasive. We can treat, even  cure, cancers we could not touch in the past, although the cost of chemotherapy drugs – a bonanza for not only the pharmaceutical companies but the hospitals that get paid a huge markup from insurers for administering them – makes them often unavailable to those who are poor and uninsured.

But there have been other things that have not changed. Indeed, have often gotten worse. This is the main focus of Nuila’s book, the social conditions that so many people, especially poor people, live in that have such a major negative impact upon their health. Calling them the “social determinants of health” is largely accurate, although the “socioeconomic determinants of health” would be more so, but it tends to almost make it sound trivial. It is not trivial. The socioeconomic conditions in which people live have a far greater impact upon health than anything except, perhaps, genetics. Certainly more than medical care, which accounts by most estimates for at best 10% of health, although it is where we as a society spend more than 90% of our health-related money. It has far more impact than all those diet/exercise/lifestyle factors, or vitamin/mineral/“natural supplements” that are promoted by those who are true believers as well as those who see this as their way to cash in.

It is shocking and distressing to me that conditions for poor people are not better than they were so long ago, and are in fact worse. The same groups of people who have always been pushed into this category, especially Black and Latino and Native peoples, and indeed poor white people, have been supplemented by immigrants from all over the globe who our society treats just as badly. And even more, supplemented by the NON-poor, working and middle class Americans who often have trouble getting the health care that they need – and deserve – because of limits imposed by insurance companies and health systems, which all operate as if they were for profit.

It is still surprising to me, because although I intellectually know better, much of my instinctive reaction is deep-seated and believes that history moves in a positive direction and things tend to get better. Said so much more articulately by Dr. King, “The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice,” it resonates with me as much as I fear it is not so. My own perspective is generational; grandparents who were immigrants and low-income, parents raised in the Depression and in WWII, myself raised after the war thinking we were now middle-class (we were working class); better off than our parents were growing up. It was in that period that CEO salaries relative to average workers were “only” about 30x as much (not the hundreds of times as much as today), unions were stronger, the civil rights movement was gaining ground. See, e.g., this from the Economic Policy Institute from 2019 showing CEO salaries gained 940%  since 1978 while average worker salary was up only 12%!

But now it is much worse. It is moving backwards, except for the wealthiest – and by the wealthiest I mean the really wealthiest. Midwifed by the Republican party (but abetted by the Democrats), especially since the Reagan 1980s, we have become a society in which not just a disproportionate share (which was always), not just most, but virtually everything goes to the wealthiest. This Oxfam report (January 2023) shows that in the last 2 years, the top 1% has accumulated nearly twice as much as everyone else in the world put together!! This is what it is all about. Yes, there is racism, and sexism, and anti-LBGTQ+ ism, and they are terrible and they often make people’s individual lives terrible, and should be fought against ceaselessly. But it is the gangster capitalism (Noam Chomsky’s term) in which there is literally no limit to the greed and the amount of money a few people have, hundreds of times more than they or their descendants could ever spend.

This is the trend in our world and our nation while the people who seek health care at Ben Taub Hospital in Houston or Stroger Hospital in Chicago or their equivalents, not to mention those who live in places where there are not public hospitals, not to mention those from all the parts of the world to whom coming to Houston or Chicago seems like it would be Heaven, get sick and sicker and die. In fact, contrary to the proclamations of right-wing pundits, all of these problems can be solved with money. It should be the money now being amassed by the richest individuals and corporations, including those in health care (providers and insurers and pharmaceutical and device manufacturers) could, and SHOULD, be used to provide medical care, but more important provide the conditions necessary for health. For EVERY person to have adequate and healthful food, to have adequate and warm housing, to have an opportunity for an education as far as their drive will take them, to have a job to feed themselves and their family. There is enough money to do this, and yet it is being socked away in private pockets so deeply it will never be touched.

In 1850, the Frenchman Frederic Bastiat wrote in “La Loi” that "When plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men, they create for themselves, in the course of time, a legal system that authorizes it, and a moral code that glorifies it." They get to do this because we enable them. Directly, our politicians enable them; while Republicans and Democrats keep our attention focused on “culture wars”, both parties (except for the most progressive Democrats) depend upon and enable them. Indirectly, it is the rest of us, who do not demand that the politicians we elect fight for the interests of the people. If the 10,000 or so Americans worth $100M or more disappeared tomorrow, no one would miss them except (presumably) their families and the politicians who have become accustomed to being owned by them. If they averaged just $100M each, that would be $1 TRILLION ($1,000,000,000,000), but of course that is an underestimate since many are worth billions, or tens of billions.

It is well past time to take that, both in taxes and in other changes in public policy, and use it for the people.